Episode #196

Letting Go & CBT

Around the time of the holidays or even just in everyday life, our expectations can get the best of us.

Why do we have trouble with letting go?

How can you figure out if you’re struggling to let go of something?

How can you use CBT tools to finally let go?

Join me, Dr Julie Osborn, as I share with you the CBT tools that can help you learn to let go.

Click to listen now!

 

Full Episode Transcript

Hi, welcome to my CBT podcast. This is Dr. Julie. I'm a Doctor of Psychology and a Licensed Clinical Social Worker specializing in Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy. I'm here to help you bring the power of CBT into your own life.

So thanks for being with me. I hope everybody's doing well.

Thanks for being with me.

I have some really exciting news to share before we get into today's podcast that I've been excited to let you guys know about. I wrote a book. I am an author, and my book is called The ABC's of CBT: Make Decisions Based on What's Best for You, Not How You Feel. If everything goes correctly, it should be available on Amazon on December 8th of this year, and I will give you guys more information when it's actually up. I'm pretty excited.

I used feedback I've gotten from my listeners about how they really appreciate how I teach CBT in an easy, simple way, so I've kept that my focus with my book. I have a bunch of chapters. I talk about depression and anxiety and shame and fear and people pleasing and boundaries and staying well, and lots of different stuff. I go over the tools and add some new tweaks with the thought record. I'm really excited about it, and I'm excited I get to share all this with everybody.

I will be putting the word out on my Instagram page under My CBT Podcast if you follow me there, and on my Facebook page, YouTube, and TikTok, which are all under Dr. Julie Osborn. It will be on my website as well with all the information. I thought it'd be a good time to put it out for the holidays. It might be a nice gift for yourself or someone you think may benefit. I've been encouraged by a lot of different people for a long time, and I just didn't feel like it was the right moment. It all came together for me. I'm really proud of my final product, and I hope you guys will get a lot out of it. A few more weeks and hopefully you will be able to purchase it yourself.

Today I wanted to do a podcast on letting go. This can help with the holidays coming up and our expectations, but in general, we all have a hard time letting go, myself included. Many of the clients I work with cover this topic, so I wanted to talk to you guys about it a little more.

My last podcast, number 193 I think, talked about the arrival fantasy, and this is a really nice connection with that. In the arrival fantasy episode, I talked about why we keep waiting for life to become what we imagined: as soon as I get this, as soon as I get that, then my life will start. Sometimes this is connected to letting go. We aren't struggling to let go of what happened. We're struggling to let go of what we wanted to happen. Let me say that again: we aren't struggling to let go of what happened, we're struggling to let go of what we wanted to happen. I think there's a good overlay with the arrival fantasy podcast, so if you haven't listened to that one yet, you can check that out as well. With what I'm going to share with you guys today, I think you'll find a little something you relate to.

So why do we have trouble letting go, and how can CBT help you with this? It's one of the most difficult parts of being human. Intellectually, we may know something's over. Maybe a relationship changed, and we know the past cannot be rewritten. Or maybe a situation is beyond our control. But emotionally, we continue to hold on. Sometimes we do this because we're afraid of what comes next. Sometimes we're searching for answers, maybe even justice, closure, or a different ending. And other times, letting go feels like accepting something we never wanted to happen.

From a CBT perspective, difficulty letting go is often connected to your thoughts, your beliefs, your emotional attachments, and behaviors that keep you emotionally connected to the past. That's why it's so difficult. Just as I talk out loud, I can think, "Oh yep, I can relate to this. I remember when it was hard for me to let go, or when I wanted a different outcome and I was like, this just can't be what's happening." It makes it hard to let go.

I want to say something really important. A really important distinction is that letting go does not mean forgetting. It doesn't mean you're approving of what happened. You're not excusing it, and you're not pretending that something didn't matter. It means learning to stop allowing something we cannot change to continually control our present. Super important, so I'm going to say it one more time. Letting go doesn't mean forgetting, approving, excusing, or pretending that something didn't matter. It means learning to stop allowing something we cannot change to continually control our present. That's really powerful, and I think it can be very empowering when you can start to let go.

So let's talk first about why it's so difficult. There are a lot of different psychological reasons we struggle to release and let go of people, experiences, our expectations, and our disappointments.

The first is that we want a different outcome. One of the biggest obstacles to letting go is our desire for things to have turned out differently. Some examples you may relate to: wishing a relationship had worked out; wanting someone to apologize or acknowledge the harm they caused, which is a big one; regretting a decision we made years ago; wishing we had recognized someone's intentions sooner; and wanting our children, family members, or partners to make different choices. With wanting a different outcome, the underlying thought might be, "If I keep thinking about this, maybe I can find a way to make sense of it or change how I feel." So you end up ruminating, and that makes it really difficult to accept circumstances that cannot be changed, especially if it's about someone else. We cannot change other people. We do not have control over them. So instead of thinking, "If I keep thinking about this, maybe I can find a way to make sense of it or change how I feel," a more balanced thought might be, "I wish things had been different, but continuing to replay what happened will not change the outcome. I can acknowledge my disappointment and still move forward." That's a good balanced thought.

Another reason it's hard to let go is when you confuse letting go with giving up. You might believe that letting go means you're surrendering, you're losing, or you're admitting defeat. If that's what you're thinking, it's going to be really hard to let go. Some examples might be: "If I stop being angry, they win." "If I move on, it means what happened didn't matter." "If I stop trying, I'm giving up on the relationship." And "If I accept this, I'm saying it was okay." Those are all hot thoughts, super hot thoughts. These beliefs often involve all-or-nothing thinking, and we mistakenly believe that we only have two choices: we can either keep fighting emotionally, or we have to completely dismiss what happened. Not true. That's the all-or-nothing, one or the other. We're looking for shades of gray. A more balanced thought would be, "I can recognize that something was wrong without allowing it to occupy my emotional energy forever." Forever. A lot of people let things affect them forever, and we want to change that, because you can recognize that something was wrong without allowing it to occupy your emotional energy forever.

Another reason it's hard to let go is that we might be afraid of the unknown. Sometimes we hold on to the familiar pain because an uncertain future feels more frightening. I know that sounds like, "What? I don't want to hold on to my pain." But if it's familiar, your brain says, "Oh, I know this. I can handle what's going on, but I don't know what would happen if I let go. That's really frightening." Even an unhealthy relationship, an unsatisfying situation, or an old identity can still provide a sense of familiarity. We like things to be familiar, and our brain likes things to be familiar. The intolerance of that uncertainty can make it so difficult to move forward, and our minds might prefer a predictable, even painful, situation over an unfamiliar possibility. That's where all the what-if thinking comes in: "But what if that happens? At least I know what's happening now. At least I know how to handle the situation now." A healthier thought you could have is that you don't need to know exactly what comes next to take one healthy step forward. Just one. One baby step. What's one thing you could do that would be healthier for you in letting go of whatever you're holding on to?

Another reason it's hard to let go is that we're attached to the story we created. We all develop stories about how our lives should unfold, and with "should," you end up shaming yourself because it didn't work out the way you thought it should. You might believe that your marriage should last forever, or your children should follow a particular path, or your hard work should produce a certain outcome. You might also believe that people should treat you the way you treat them. It would be nice, but we know that doesn't always happen. Or that life should become easier as we get older. That's not true either. These are things we get attached to about how we think our story should be, and we don't want to let go. When your reality doesn't match these expectations, you end up becoming attached to the life you thought you would have, and that's going to cause a lot of depression. These rigid expectations and should statements contribute to a lot of emotional distress. A healthier thought is, "I had expectations about how my life would unfold, but I can learn to build meaning and fulfillment from the life I actually have, and I can handle what it looks like."

So those are a bunch of reasons why it's hard to let go. I also want to talk to you guys about the CBT cycle that keeps us from letting go. Consider someone, or maybe it's yourself, who has experienced a painful relationship ending. That's never fun. Why is it so hard to move on from that? Let's say the situation, the event, is that the relationship ends. Your hot thoughts might be, "I should have seen this coming." "What if I had done things differently?" "I need to understand why this happened." We all want to know why, and it can drive you crazy when you don't have the answers. I understand that's really hard. But these are the hot thoughts. So you might feel sad, angry, regretful, maybe guilty, and probably some anxiety as well.

So what do you do? You end up replaying conversations. You might check social media all day and all night. You keep seeking explanations; maybe you're leaving messages for whoever ended the relationship: "Please just explain, please tell me why." And you may imagine alternative endings, just fantasizing. Those are the behaviors that keep you holding on and not letting go. You remain emotionally connected to the loss, and that makes it difficult for you to move forward.

Instead, with your CBT tools, you guys can challenge the unhelpful thinking, the hot thoughts you have. You can reduce ruminating about it. You can change these reinforcing behaviors, like checking social media and seeking explanations. And you can redirect your attention toward your present-day values and activities: "Although this is so hard for me, how do I want to live my life today?"

The important insight is that sometimes your attempts to find closure actually keep you emotionally attached to what you're trying to leave behind. You've got to be really honest with yourself and ask, "What is this behavior of holding on really creating?" We can tell ourselves lots of hot thoughts, like "I deserve to know" and "I'll feel better once I find out." But there are lots of times we're left with no answers, and we're either going to stay stuck in that place, or we're going to create a life based on our values and what's important, and get present. You can do this with the tools that you have, and many of you have probably done this already. I've done this in my life. I don't think I was aware of it at the time, until I learned my CBT tools. They helped me say, "Okay, these are some things I've got to let go of, because holding on to them is not serving me anymore."

Let's go over some of the cognitive distortions that make it difficult to let go. There are lots of different thinking patterns that keep you emotionally stuck. If you're ruminating, you might tell yourself, "If I keep replaying what happened, I'll figure it out. I've got to figure it out." Ruminating actually causes you to be more depressed. With should statements, as I mentioned already: "Things should have turned out differently." If you're personalizing, you might be thinking, "If I had been different, this wouldn't have happened." The all-or-nothing we talked about already: "If I let go, it means I didn't care." You might do some emotional reasoning, which is one of the cognitive distortions. The thought could be, "I still hurt, so I must not be ready to make progress." That gives you permission to stay stuck and not let go. You might have catastrophic thoughts and tell yourself, "I will never be happy again." That is catastrophizing. You might be a fortune teller, thinking you can see the future, and think that you're never going to find another meaningful relationship. These two I hear all the time: "I'll never be happy again." "I'll never find another meaningful relationship. I'll never find somebody I'm going to love again." And you may overgeneralize: "People always disappoint me." That's an overgeneralization.

So there are lots of different hot thoughts we can have that are connected to these cognitive distortions. A really important lesson in CBT is that we can acknowledge the truth of our experiences without accepting every conclusion our minds draw from them. I know we want to finish the story; we want an answer. But we can acknowledge the truth of our experiences: "This is a breakup," or "I lost this job," or whatever it might be. "That's really hard, and that is my truth. But I don't have to accept every conclusion that I come up with, because it doesn't mean it's true just because I'm thinking it."

Let's talk about exactly what you're holding on to. Sometimes we think we're holding on to a person or a situation when we're actually holding on to something even deeper than that. I'm going to go over a few different things that might resonate with you.

One might be the need for an apology. This is really common. You want someone to acknowledge what they did and understand how they hurt you, and you may never get it. You can reframe your thinking by telling yourself, "An apology would be meaningful, but my ability to heal does not have to depend entirely on someone else's willingness to take responsibility." Off the top of my head, and I know I've shared this with you guys many times: when my mom and dad divorced, my mom left. I know we all have to deal with things like this at some time in our lives, but she never really apologized. She's passed away now. I love her, may she rest in peace. But she always just kept saying, "It was what I needed to do. It's what I needed to do." At some point I realized I needed to let go of that, and I needed to forgive for myself so I could move on and not be stuck thinking, "Oh my God, how can you not apologize? How can you not see how that affected me, my brother, and my sister?" I didn't get that apology, and I was holding on to it. I needed to learn how to let go and move on.

The next one is the need for closure. Oh my goodness, I hear this all the time: "I can't move on. How am I going to find closure?" You believe that you can't move forward until you understand exactly why something happened: "I've got to know exactly what it was." But let's reframe this: "I may never have all the answers, but I can still make peace with some unanswered questions." Some really powerful CBT tools can help you walk through this part and know that you may not get the closure you want, but you can create what that looks like for yourself.

Some people get really stuck in needing to be right. You continually argue your position in your head because you want validation that you were treated unfairly. Totally legit. Totally legit. But you may not get it. Instead, you could tell yourself, "I don't need everyone to agree with my interpretation for my experience to matter. This is my experience. This is how I'm interpreting it. This is my perception. Everyone doesn't need to understand it, but this is my truth, and I need to work through that."

Another reason you might be holding on is that you're hoping someone's going to change. Don't we all? We remain attached to someone's potential rather than accepting their consistent behavior. I always say, "I don't have time to wait for your potential." That means it's not here right now. And that's what we tell ourselves to give ourselves permission to hold on to a relationship, thinking they'll change. Instead: "I can care about someone's potential while making decisions based on their actual behavior." I've had lots of people, especially if they're involved with someone who's an addict or an alcoholic, say, "Oh my God, they're so nice when they're sober. They're so nice when they're not drinking or doing drugs." And I'm like, "I'm sure they are." You all know I'm married to somebody in recovery. But they are using. They are drinking. They are using drugs. Their potential is not there, and you can't wait to see if it's ever going to come. What's your potential? And what are you going to do for yourself instead?

One last reason you might be holding on is your former identity. What I mean by that is you may struggle to release an identity, a role, a relationship, or a chapter of life that once gave you purpose. That's hard. Just hearing that out loud makes me feel sad, because it's really hard to release those different aspects of your life. But instead you can say, which is so true, "My identity can evolve, and losing one role does not mean losing who I am." What would a role be? Maybe you got divorced, and now you're not a wife or a husband. Or whatever your role might have been, even in your career. Whatever that looks like for you, it is a loss, but your identity is going to evolve. Hopefully your identity is going to evolve, because that means you're growing, you're trying new things, you're having new experiences, and you can create whatever identity is going to serve you best. Losing one role does not mean losing yourself.

I want to talk about another aspect here: the difference between acceptance and resignation. A lot of people struggle with this, and it's really important to understand what acceptance is and what resignation is. I'll give you some examples. Acceptance means you're going to acknowledge your reality. You're going to recognize what is outside of your control. You're going to choose where to direct your energy. You're going to make room for difficult emotions, and you're going to move forward with your intentions. That's acceptance. That sounds good to me.

Resignation means you believe nothing can improve. You feel powerless about everything. You give up on yourself. You suppress the difficult emotions, and you remain passive. There's nothing healthy about that. You are not resigning here. You are accepting so you can move forward.

Accepting also means that you have a problem that you can't fix, so you need to accept it and find ways to move on. That's part of what I meant by acknowledging reality. And acceptance, I tell everybody, is an ebb and flow. One day I'm like, "Oh yeah, I accept this. I'm good. I'm going to move forward." And then maybe the next day I'm like, "I don't know if I'm really there. I'm not really accepting it today. It doesn't feel good. I've got to keep working on my tools and reminding myself that I need to accept my reality, focus on what is in my control, choose a different direction, address all the difficult emotions I'm feeling, and then move forward with whatever my intention is going to be for myself." And maybe it's just for today. I don't need to worry about tomorrow. Just take it one day at a time, one step at a time, one hour at a time.

Acceptance doesn't mean that we like what happened. It means we stop requiring reality to be different before we allow ourselves to live. That goes back to, "I can't fix the problem," and you don't want to wait for things to be the way you want them to be. "I can still move on and have my life." That's empowering, and that's acceptance.

Let's talk about some basic CBT strategies that can help you let go.

Strategy one, I would say, is to separate what you can control from what you cannot control. That's super important. Can I change what happened? Can I control another person's feelings or decisions? No. Can I control how I interpret the situation? Can I choose how I respond today? Where would my energy be better invested?

There's a little exercise I want you to do. You've got to get a piece of paper out. I want you to write down what is within your control. Your choices are within your control, so you can write down those choices. What are your boundaries? How do you respond? What are your priorities? And what are your next steps? That's within your control. One more time: within your control are your choices, your boundaries, how you respond, what your priorities are, and your next steps.

What's outside of your control? The past, others' opinions, others' decisions, whether someone apologizes, and every future outcome. That is what is outside of your control. It would be good to write down the aspects that are in your control, to be more clear: the choices, boundaries, and other things I talked about. It's really important to understand the difference, because people become very anxious and depressed, and have all the negative feelings, because they're focusing on what is outside of their control. It happens all the time, every day. You really need to ask yourself, "What do I have control over? Because that's where I want to focus."

Another strategy is to challenge the need to keep replaying the past. Ooh, people do this all the time. We get stuck there because we ruminate, and it can create the illusion, everybody, that we are solving a problem when we're actually repeating the same thoughts. So I want you to ask yourself: Am I learning something new from this thought? Have I already considered this possibility? Is reflecting on this helping me make a decision? Am I trying to solve something that cannot be changed? Then, instead of thinking, "Why did this happen to me?" I want you to replace it with, "Given that this happened, what would be a healthy next step?" Ask yourself those questions instead of thinking, "Why did this happen to me? Why me? Why me?" A lot of times we're not going to get the answers. Instead, own it and focus on what you have control over by saying, "Given that this happened, what would be a healthy next step for me?" Because that, I have control over.

You also want to be flexible in your thought process. Instead of insisting that your life must unfold according to your expectations, practice developing alternative ways of thinking. People get very stuck on "Things need to be the way I want them to be and meet my expectations." I'll give you an example. A rigid thought might be, "I thought my life would look completely different at this age." A more flexible way of thinking would be, "My life looks different from what I imagined. That doesn't mean it cannot still be meaningful." Another example: a rigid thought is, "I will never get over what happened." A flexible way of thinking would be, "I may always remember what happened, but my relationship with that memory can change." That's being a little more flexible, instead of saying "I can never get over this," because that is really going to keep you stuck.

You also want to change the behaviors that keep you attached. What am I doing that is getting in the way of letting go? Sometimes letting go requires behavioral changes, not just changing your thoughts. I always tell you guys, it's CBT: cognitive behavioral therapy. The B is very important. The goal isn't to avoid reminders or feelings at all costs. It's to stop reinforcing habits that keep you stuck.

Another thing you can do is practice grieving what you cannot change. What would that look like? Letting go sometimes involves grief, because it's a loss. You might need to grieve a relationship that didn't work, a childhood you didn't receive, an apology that never came, a missed opportunity, a version of yourself that you've outgrown, and even a future that may never happen for you. Grief and acceptance can coexist. Moving forward does not require you to stop caring about what you lost. I'll say that again: moving forward does not require you to stop caring about what you lost. You can accept and move forward, but you can still feel sad, have the grief, and walk through that. They can coexist for sure.

So what if we did a thought record? What am I holding on to, what do I want to let go of, and how can I learn to let go? It's not an exact thought record, but it's in that format, so you guys can get a visual here.

First, ask yourself, "What am I having difficulty letting go of?" Just start there. Whether it's a relationship, a disappointment, maybe a regret in your life, or a conflict, what is it that you're having difficulty letting go of? Start there.

The second step is to ask, "Why am I holding on to it? Do I need an apology, answers, validation, a different outcome?" All the things I've talked about with you today.

Number three, ask yourself, "What beliefs are keeping me stuck?" Maybe it's one of the ones I mentioned, like "I can't move on until I understand why." That can keep you stuck.

Number four, ask, "What's in my control and what isn't?" Identify what you can influence and what you need to accept.

Number five, ask yourself, "What would a healthier, more balanced thought be?" You can acknowledge what happened without allowing it to define your future. Come up with a better balanced thought for yourself.

And finally, "What's one action I can take to move forward?" What's that one baby step I'm asking you to take today? Whatever that might look like for you. Maybe it's even just writing all of this down. That would be a great first step.

Before I finish up here, I want to talk a little bit about a deeper connection, which is letting go and your childhood experiences. For some people, difficulty letting go has roots in early relationships and childhood experiences, and a lot of us can get stuck there. For example, someone who experienced abandonment may struggle to release relationships, even unhealthy ones. Oh my, I'm talking about myself in my past, but definitely, for sure, I held on to unhealthy relationships because I was so afraid of being abandoned. Someone who grew up feeling responsible for their parents' emotions may struggle to let go of guilt. Someone who experienced inconsistent affection may hold tightly to relationships because losing them feels threatening. And one more: someone who experienced emotional neglect may continually seek validation from people who are unable or unwilling to provide it.

That's where we repeat. We create what we fear the most. We're afraid we're going to experience emotional neglect, and we actually create it, because we continually seek validation from people who aren't going to provide it. Very unconsciously, with all of these examples I gave you, we believe, "If I can just get that, then I'll be healed. I'll be okay." But I'm seeking it from someone outside myself, and the healing needs to come from within. I need to learn to let go, and not hope someone's going to fix that for me, because that doesn't happen.

If we think about this with our CBT tools, these experiences can contribute to the deeply held core beliefs I've talked to you guys about. It might be, "I'm not good enough." "People will eventually leave me." "I have to work hard to be loved." "If I let go, I'll be alone." And "I'm responsible for keeping everyone happy." Whew, that's exhausting. But these are the core beliefs that are creating these behaviors. We talk about the core beliefs, and then we have the behavioral strategies we use to try to make ourselves feel good, but they're really coming from the negative core belief. When the strategies don't work, we go right back to the core belief, because we haven't worked on it. These can influence your adult relationships and make letting go especially difficult. So you want to identify the underlying beliefs, examine whether they are still true, and develop healthier beliefs about yourself and your relationships.

That's a lot, I know. But you can look at this and say, "I can start working on my underlying beliefs. I can start focusing on what I have control over and what I don't. I can start developing better beliefs about myself and my relationships." Just pick one thing. That's all.

Let me give you a few more questions. I know I've said a lot today. There are just so many great aspects of CBT for helping you learn to let go. Some questions you can ask yourself are: Why do I sometimes prefer familiar unhappiness over unfamiliar possibilities? Why is it so difficult to let go of people who hurt me? Am I holding on to the person, or to the hope of who I wanted them to be? Why do I believe closure is what I need before I can move forward? When does reflection become rumination? Am I reflecting, or am I ruminating? How do I let go of the life I thought I would have? That's really hard, and it's painful just to say out loud. That goes back to the idea that you can grieve it and accept it at the same time.

So remember, letting go is not losing. It is making a choice in your life. Sometimes we hold on because we want the answers, the apologies, the justice, or we just want a different ending. We replay the conversations, we revisit the old decisions, and we imagine what might have happened if things had gone differently. But eventually, we have to ask ourselves an important question: Is holding on helping me heal, or is it keeping me connected to something I can no longer change?

I want you to ask yourself that. Are you holding on to something that you cannot change? That's really important to think about. Maybe you didn't think about that before, because you thought, "I can change it if I just do all these things." "Is holding on helping me heal?" is the first part of the question, and you can answer it yes or no. If it's a no, then think about all the things I've shared today, and ask, "Why am I staying connected to something I can't change that is not going to help me heal?"

Through our CBT tools, I've taught you guys that we can't always change our circumstances, but we can definitely examine the thoughts and beliefs that keep us emotionally stuck. Letting go doesn't mean it didn't matter. It means you're recognizing that your past deserves to be acknowledged, but it doesn't have to determine your future. We can learn from yesterday without continuing to live there. "That was my past. This is my present. What do I want it to look like?"

I hope this gave you some insight into yourself, if there's something in your life you haven't been able to let go of. Maybe just hearing some of the behaviors made you realize, "Oh, I'm not letting go of this." Sometimes we don't even realize we're not letting go of something, but it's coming out in our behavior. There are all different ways to get there, and I hope you're able to have that insight, acknowledge it, and then start using these CBT tools to help you make some changes.

As always, I hope this was helpful. Please share it with anyone who may benefit from it as well. You guys know how to find me on my website at mycognitivebehavioraltherapy.com.

You can find me on Instagram under My CBT Podcast, and as Dr. Julie Osborn on Facebook, YouTube, and TikTok.

Please keep sharing your thoughts, your concerns, and your questions. I love hearing from you and getting your feedback, and letting me know how the podcasts are working in your life.

Please hit the subscribe button to make sure you never miss another episode. It's all free.

And again, I'm really excited about my book, and I'll keep you guys up to date on when it'll be available. It's another journey we can go on together.

And as always, make decisions based on what's best for you, not how you feel.